HOPIQ SCORE
The Best American Stouts
78 beers from 71 breweries · Ranked by style authenticity — not marketing
These rankings are dynamic. As more people rate, match and like beers on hopIQ, community signals will increasingly shape the results alongside style authenticity and award recognition.
American Stout is the specialty category American craft turned into a global reference. Of the 73 American stouts on this ranking, 29 are Imperial Stout — a sub-style that in the American craft scene became a canvas for the two innovations that defined 21st-century stout brewing: barrel-aging (particularly bourbon-barrel and rum-barrel programmes) and the pastry-stout adjunct tradition (coffee, cocoa, coconut, marshmallow, vanilla). Neither existed at scale in world brewing before American craft breweries built the categories around them.
The hopIQ ranking captures the breadth: Deschutes Obsidian Stout, AleSmith Speedway Stout, Superstition Breakfast Stout, plus a wide tail of Oatmeal, Milk, Coffee, Foreign Extra, and specialty variants including the Barrel-Aged Imperial Stout sub-style. Founders Kentucky Breakfast Stout, Bell's Expedition Stout, and Deschutes The Abyss are absent from this list only because they missed the qualifying threshold — the American Imperial Stout category is deeper than any 50-beer ranking can capture, and the top of this list represents beers that combine consistent style-precision scores with award recognition rather than one-off release hype.
How this ranking works
The hopIQ Score weights style authenticity (80%), user engagement (10%), notability (10%), and award history. Active, in-production beers only — non-alcoholic excluded. No paid placement — order follows the data alone. Ranking spans 78 beers from 71 breweries.
Top 5 of 50
Left Hand Milk Stout NitroBest Overall#503 worldwide
ABV
6%
Bitterness
Noticeably bitter
Colour
dark 40
America's most celebrated nitro stout. Pour hard over a spoon for a cascading creamy head — then drink deeply of dark chocolate, coffee and silky smooth milk sugar sweetness. Left Hand engineered a nitrogen widget into the bottle, creating…America's most celebrated nitro stout. Pour hard over a spoon for a cascading creamy head — then drink deeply of dark chocolate, coffee and silky smooth milk sugar sweetness. Left Hand engineered a nitrogen widget into the bottle, creating a draught stout experience at home. Multiple GABF gold medals.
Zonker Stout
ABV
6%
Bitterness
Noticeably bitter
Colour
dark 40
One of the most-awarded beers in America — a rich, well-balanced foreign-style stout with a generous amount of roasted barley, sweet chocolatey malt, and a smooth finish. So decorated that Snake River reportedly no longer even enters it in…One of the most-awarded beers in America — a rich, well-balanced foreign-style stout with a generous amount of roasted barley, sweet chocolatey malt, and a smooth finish. So decorated that Snake River reportedly no longer even enters it in competitions.
Hauling Oats Oatmeal Stout
ABV
5.7%
Bitterness
Noticeably bitter
Colour
dark 40
A roasty, easy-drinking stout with oatmeal smoothness — the kind of dark beer that converts people who think they don't like dark beer. Coffee and chocolate notes without the weight. Ranked here for style-fit against the Stout reference and award history in Stout-specific categories.
Which of these beers fits your taste?
Build your Beer DNA and see which of these top beers fit your taste — free, in two minutes.
Build my Beer DNA4
Marble Imperial Stout
ABV
11%
Bitterness
Very bitter
Colour
dark 60
Marble's highest-rated beer on BeerAdvocate. Rich dark chocolate, espresso and roasted malt in a thick, warming body. One of New Mexico's most acclaimed dark beers and a Great American Beer Festival medal winner. Ranked here for style-fit against the Stout reference and award history in Stout-specific categories.
5
Nitro McCarthy StoutBest Session
ABV
4.2%
Bitterness
Noticeably bitter
Colour
dark 35
Alaska's original canned nitro stout — a dry Irish stout with a nitrogen widget that pours the cascading tan head and silky mouthfeel you can usually only get on draft. Roasted coffee and dark chocolate up front, dry finish, low ABV. The…Alaska's original canned nitro stout — a dry Irish stout with a nitrogen widget that pours the cascading tan head and silky mouthfeel you can usually only get on draft. Roasted coffee and dark chocolate up front, dry finish, low ABV. The first beer 49th State ever brewed, still on the flagship shelf.
Ranks 6–10
6
Nitro Irish Stout
A Colorado take on the classic Irish Stout, served on nitro — cascading tan head, silky mouthfeel, and a low-carb velvet across the palate. Roasted coffee and dark chocolate lead, with a whisper of bitter cocoa on the finish. Not heavy,…A Colorado take on the classic Irish Stout, served on nitro — cascading tan head, silky mouthfeel, and a low-carb velvet across the palate. Roasted coffee and dark chocolate lead, with a whisper of bitter cocoa on the finish. Not heavy, not sweet — session Irish Stout done with mountain-brewery patience and care.
7
Schlafly Oatmeal Stout
A classic British-style stout with oat flakes in the mash for a smooth, creamy body. Dark and roasty with chocolate and coffee notes, balanced by just enough bitterness and a nutty character from the roasted barley. One of Schlafly's most…A classic British-style stout with oat flakes in the mash for a smooth, creamy body. Dark and roasty with chocolate and coffee notes, balanced by just enough bitterness and a nutty character from the roasted barley. One of Schlafly's most consistent year-round performers.
8
Maggie's
Maggie's is a Dry Irish Stout that defies the heavy-bodied reputation of its family. Light in frame yet dark in colour, it pivots toward roasted grain and a touch of charcoal—the roasty character sits clean and purposeful, never scorched.…Maggie's is a Dry Irish Stout that defies the heavy-bodied reputation of its family. Light in frame yet dark in colour, it pivots toward roasted grain and a touch of charcoal—the roasty character sits clean and purposeful, never scorched. The smoothness runs through the middle, creating a beer that satisfies without weight, making it sessionable across an evening or afternoon. The dryness in the finish is the signature move: it pulls back sweetness and leaves the palate alert, ready for the next pour. At 4.2%, this is a stout built for drinking, not merely tasting.
9
Oatmeal Stout
A smooth, full-bodied oatmeal stout with a velvety body from flaked oats. Roasted malt, dark chocolate and coffee notes give way to a creamy, gently sweet finish. A cozy, sessionable dark beer that's a taproom favourite when the Lowcountry…A smooth, full-bodied oatmeal stout with a velvety body from flaked oats. Roasted malt, dark chocolate and coffee notes give way to a creamy, gently sweet finish. A cozy, sessionable dark beer that's a taproom favourite when the Lowcountry finally cools down.
10
Boston Irish Stout
Harpoon's Boston Irish Stout is sessionable dry stout done right — at 4.3%, it trades imperial weight for creamy texture, roasted malt depth, and a clean, smooth finish that never punches above its ABV. Full-bodied but never heavy, it…Harpoon's Boston Irish Stout is sessionable dry stout done right — at 4.3%, it trades imperial weight for creamy texture, roasted malt depth, and a clean, smooth finish that never punches above its ABV. Full-bodied but never heavy, it drinks like a confident neighborhood regular who knows exactly who they are. The kind of stout you can have two of without regret.
The taste landscape
Of the 50 top beers, 38 lean malt-forward and 2 lean hop-forward.