Analysing flavor profile...
Searching 900+ beers...
Ranking matches...
Finding your perfect match
BEER COMPARISON
THE HOPIQ TAKE
This comparison is about what Irish stout can be beyond the ubiquitous option. Guinness is the stout everyone has had and most people like — roasty, slightly bitter, that unmistakable nitro pour. Murphy's is less famous and better in a quiet way: smoother, less bitter, slightly more chocolatey, with a creaminess on draught that matches Guinness and then adds a gentler roast. Guinness tastes of stout as a genre. Murphy's tastes of stout as a specific thing — Cork-brewed, unhurried, slightly softer. If you've never tried Murphy's because Guinness is always there, that's the comparison worth making.
SIDE BY SIDE
| Guinness Draught | Murphy's Irish Stout | |
| ABV | 4.2% | 4.0% |
| IBU | 45 | 36 |
| Colour | Opaque black, SRM 40+ | Opaque black, SRM 40+ |
| Finish | Dry roast, slight bitterness, long | Chocolate, smooth, gentle |
| Brewery | Guinness | Murphy's Brewery |
FLAVOUR PROFILE
Guinness Draught
Murphy's Irish Stout
TASTING NOTES
Guinness Draught
The pour is the ritual and the pour is correct. Dark ruby-black, that slow cascade, the cream head settling. The nose is coffee and dry roast, a faint metallic note from the nitrogen. The first sip is cooler than you expect and softer — nitrogen kills the carbonation bite and the bitterness lands gentler than the aroma promises. Roasted barley dominates, slightly acrid, very dry in the finish. Low ABV for the impression of richness it gives.
Murphy's Irish Stout
Looks almost identical to Guinness — that's the nitrogen and the dark malt. But the first sip is noticeably different: less bitter, rounder, with a chocolate note that Guinness doesn't quite have. The creaminess is there from the nitro pour but it sits differently — less coffee, more milk chocolate. The finish is gentler, cleaner, without Guinness's characteristic dry, slightly acrid close. It's easier to drink but somehow feels less heroic for it.
WHEN TO CHOOSE WHICH
Choose Guinness Draught when…
Choose Murphy's Irish Stout when…
RELATED COMPARISONS