Beers similar to Midnight Temptation

Prairie Artisan Ales

Porter·United States·5.5% ABV·One of 222 Porters in hopIQ·

hopIQ found 10 beers that share Midnight Temptation's chocolate and vanilla character. A chocolate milkshake in porter form: cacao, vanilla cream and so much milk chocolate, with a chocolate-syrup note running through it. Prairie lists chocolate and lactose as allergens, which fits the milkshake idea, and its taproom list carries a 2025 edition of the beer, so it keeps coming back instead of appearing once.

Similar beers ranked by flavour match rather than popularity.Similar beers ranked by flavour, not popularity.

chocolatevanillacreamy

Explore 10 alternatives Compare with your taste

Learn about this style

What is a Porter?·Stout vs Porter — how do you tell them apart?

See all Porter in the ranking →

Also searched: alternatives to

Find alternatives →

Find alternatives →

The Kernel London Porter

Find alternatives →

Anspach & Hobday Porter

Find alternatives →

10 beers like Midnight Temptation

1

Breckenridge Vanilla Porter

Breckenridge Brewery

United States · Porter · 5.4%

TWIN

95%

FLAVOUR MATCH

Alongside Midnight on richness and sweetness.

What carries overchocolatevanillacoffeecreamyrich

Structure: very close

Structure: Very close — a touch more sweetness, a touch more texture.

Structure: very close

View beer Alternatives to Breckenridge Vanilla Porter

Tried both? Do they taste alike?

2

Northern Monk

United Kingdom · Porter · 5.2%

TWIN

92%

FLAVOUR MATCH

As with Midnight, same richness and creaminess; adds caramel notes, no sweetness.

What carries overchocolatevanillacreamyrichsmooth

Structure: very close

Compared to Midnightcaramelbreadysweet

Structure: Same structure — body, sweetness, bitterness and texture all land on the same spot.

Structure: very close

View beer Alternatives to Northern Star

Tried both? Do they taste alike?

3

Bridge Road Brewers

Australia · Porter · 6.0%

TWIN

92%

FLAVOUR MATCH

Same sweetness and creaminess as Midnight, adds fullness.

What carries overchocolatesweetvanillacreamysmooth

Structure: very close

Compared to Midnightfull-bodied

Structure: Same structure — body, sweetness, bitterness and texture all land on the same spot.

Structure: very close

View beer Alternatives to Eggster

Tried both? Do they taste alike?

Also close

More matches

Same idea, less detail — open a beer to see the full comparison.

4

Triple Point Brewing

United Kingdom · Porter · 7.0%

90%

MATCH

Mirrors Midnight's richness and creaminess — plus fullness, a notch stronger, minus sweetness.

Structure: a notch stronger

View Alternatives

5

St. Peter's Brewery

United Kingdom · Porter · 4.5%

88%

MATCH

Like Midnight on sweetness and richness — adds honey notes, sweeter, but without the creaminess.

Structure: sweeter, a notch softer

View Alternatives

6

Bourbon Barrel Aged Pumpkin Porter

Foothills Brewing

United States · Porter · 5.9%

86%

MATCH

A touch more oak notes, noticeably less bitter, no creaminess — sweetness and richness as with Midnight.

Structure: less bitter

View Alternatives

7

Kirkstall Brewery

United Kingdom · Porter · 5.5%

86%

MATCH

Keeps richness and sweetness like Midnight, adds fruit notes, drops creaminess.

Structure: very close

View Alternatives

8

Peanut Butter Chocolate

August Schell Brewing Company

United States · Porter · 6.0%

84%

MATCH

Shares creaminess and richness with Midnight; adds caramel notes, noticeably less bitter, but drops vanilla notes.

Structure: less bitter

View Alternatives

9

Salted Caramel Lucaria

Thornbridge Brewery

United Kingdom · Porter · 4.5%

84%

MATCH

Sweeter — same creaminess and richness as Midnight, adds caramel notes, sweeter, but without the vanilla notes.

Structure: sweeter, a notch softer

View Alternatives

10

Wiper and True

United Kingdom · Porter · 6.7%

83%

MATCH

Stronger — same richness and sweetness as Midnight, adds caramel notes, a notch stronger, but without the creaminess.

Structure: a notch stronger

View Alternatives