hopIQ
ENDE
Build your DNASign in

Mutton Buster Brown Ale

Tap to rate

Payette Brewing named this after Idaho's rodeo heritage, and Mutton Buster is built like a working beer: sturdy, unpretentious, honest. Toasted caramel and cocoa malt give it warmth and depth at 5.5%; the 28 IBU bitterness stays well in the background. A brown ale that tastes like it belongs in a saddle bag.

ABV
5.5%
Bitterness
Noticeably bitter
Roasted bitterness
SRM
dark23
PaceA Few
Where this beer sits
Body
lightfull-bodied
Sweetness
drysweet
Bitterness
mildbitter
Texture
crispcreamy
Balance
malt-forwardhop-forward
What makes this beer itself
toastycaramelclean
toasty
caramel
clean
chocolate
hoppy
malty
Aroma
The nose leads with toasted malt and caramel sweetness, giving an inviting, warm character.
also:nutty
not found:juicy,roasted,fruity,smoky

Tasting Notes

AI-generated sensory profile for Mutton Buster Brown Ale

◎ Appearance

Deep chestnut brown with a warm, translucent quality that catches light amber at the edges. A modest tan head forms with moderate retention and even lacing around the glass. The body is clear and well-defined, with gentle carbonation that produces a stable, workmanlike presentation.

chestnut brownclearmoderate headeven lacing

◌ Aroma

The nose leads with toasted malt and caramel sweetness, giving an inviting, warm character. Cocoa and subtle chocolate notes emerge in the mid-range, grounded by a light spice from traditional noble hops. There is no aggressive aromatic hop presence—instead, the impression is straightforward and unpretentious, like leather and saddle.

toasted malzcaramelcocoarestrained hoppy

◐ Taste

Entry is smooth and malty, with immediate toasted caramel sweetness balanced by a clean, medium body. Mid-palate reveals chocolate and nutty depth without heaviness, while noble hop bitterness (30 IBU) sits comfortably in the background, never dominating. The overall impression is honest and balanced—a working beer that does not overreach.

caramelchocolate notessmoothrestrained bitterness

◑ Finish

The finish is clean and medium in length, fading to a gentle malt dryness without residual sweetness. A faint cocoa and toast linger pleasantly, leaving the palate refreshed and ready for the next sip.

dry finishtoasty aftertaste
76
hopIQ score
Aroma
76
Taste
78
Appearance
75
Finish
75
Serve at 10–13°C

Serve at 10–13°C for the best flavour balance and aroma expression.

Pint glass

The classic — versatile, comfortable to hold and keeps the beer cool. No frills, no distractions: just the beer.

+ Sign in to add your tasting note

Food Pairing

What to eat with Mutton Buster Brown Ale

More from Payette Brewing Company

North Fork Lager
North Fork Lager
American Lager
4.8%·Mild
Find matches →
Outlaw IPA
Outlaw IPA
American IPA
6.9%·Strongly bitter
Find matches →
Payette Pale Ale
Payette Pale Ale
American Pale Ale
5.2%·Noticeably bitter
Find matches →

About American Brown Ale

Style guide · what to expect · how to find alternatives

What is a American Brown Ale?

American Brown Ale is a distinctive beer style with its own characteristic flavour, aroma and colour. Discover what makes it unique and find similar beers on hopIQ.

Finding a similar American Brown Ale

hopIQ matches by flavor profile — not just style label. A beer with the same toasty, caramel, clean character as Mutton Buster Brown Ale will score highly even if brewed in a different country or under a different sub-style name.

Compare with another beer →