hopIQ found 10 beers with the same smoky and caramel character as Bayreuther Rauchmärzen. Bayreuther's Rauchmärzen is smoked beer done with grace — beechwood smoke rises first, but beneath it sits a warm amber malt sweetness and caramel depth that keeps the beer drinking like an Märzen, not a gimmick. 5.5%, balanced between spicy smoke and malt richness. A Franconian classic that rewards slow sipping. Ranked by flavour match rather than popularity.
Closest match: Greif Rauchbier — 86%. No twin in the catalogue yet.
3 countriesmatched across 56 flavour tagsbest match 86%

No beer in the catalogue yet — these come closest.
Close on what matters, with one thing they do differently.
Same idea, less detail — open a beer to see the full comparison.