Belhaven Black Scottish Stout vs Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout: Which Should You Drink?

HOPIQ FACEOFF

Belhaven Black Scottish Stout

Belhaven Brewery

Scotland · Stout

hopIQ rank #38

86%

Overall similarity

side by side, across 56 flavour tags

Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout

Dungarvan Brewing Company

Ireland · Stout

HOPIQ TAKE

Belhaven Black Scottish Stout if you want something roasty and grain-forward with subtle sweetness, Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout if you want cleaner, drier edges with more mineral backbone. Both sit at identical ABV and IBU, so the choice really comes down to flavor profile—Scottish vs. Irish brewing philosophy in a glass. The Belhaven leans into comfort; the Dungarvan into precision.

See what fits your taste

Build your Beer DNA

hopIQ scores every beer against your palate, not the average drinker's.

WHEN TO CHOOSE WHICH

Pick Belhaven Black Scottish Stout when…

→You want comfort and sweetness without sacrificing sophistication
→You're in the mood for a stout that wraps around you rather than challenges you
→You prefer cocoa, chocolate, and subtle toffee notes

Pick Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout when…

→You want a stout with more definition and less sugar-forward character
→You prefer the crisp, dry finish of Irish brewing styles
→You're looking for something refreshing despite the dark color

SIDE BY SIDE

	Belhaven Black Scottish Stout	Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout
ABV	4.2%	4.2%
Bitterness	Noticeably bitter	Noticeably bitter
Colour	Dark	Dark
Style	Stout	Stout
Origin	Scotland	Ireland

WHAT IT TASTES OF

11 shared · 2 distinct

Both beers

roastedsmoothcreamychocolatecoffeemaltyrichtoastycleanbitter

STRUCTURE — HOW IT'S BUILT

Belhaven Black Scottish StoutDungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout

Bitterness

Body

TASTING NOTES

Belhaven Black Scottish Stout

RoastedSmoothDry

Belhaven Black hits you with immediate cocoa and dark chocolate, but there's this honeyed warmth underneath that keeps it from ever feeling austere. The body is silky—genuinely smooth for 4.2% ABV—and the finish lingers with just enough bitter coffee notes to anchor it. It's the kind of stout that tastes bigger than it is, which is exactly what Scottish brewing does best.

Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout

RoastedCreamyChocolate

Dungarvan Black Rock tastes leaner and more defined, with sharper roasted grain edges and a crisp, almost mineral dryness on the finish. There's less sweetness to hide behind here—you get clean dark malt, a whisper of ash, and a refreshing snap that makes you want the next sip immediately. It's drier in the Irish tradition, less indulgent than its Scottish cousin.

Find beers like Belhaven Black Scottish Stout

View alternatives →

Find beers like Dungarvan Black Rock Irish Stout

View alternatives →

← All comparisons